Showing posts with label Bill Gates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bill Gates. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 25, 2017

Education vs. Entrepreneurship: Why the Debate?

There are so many social media posts related to education and entrepreneurship. I have no idea why people think your education should be directly related to your richness or your company. One serious deals with learning about "things" and the other is about transactions or wealth creation. There are people who combine these on the basis of their creativity in the field they know very well or who were the first to think of the idea. It however, does not mean every computer guy will have Facebook or Google. 

The more I read about this, the more I realise it's mostly promoted by people who want to prove that they "made it" in life without education! Yet, the same people will always be pushing their children to study and get an education. That should clearly remind you that this is not an area of comparison. Otherwise, they would ensure none of their children stepped a foot in class.

I have been promoted to reflect on this issue based on a statement that is attributed to a Dr. Sokuni which dangerously goes as far as saying "Education is important for you to READ, WRITE AND LEARN HOW TO SPEAK ENGLISH so you can communicate,  transact and do your own Business" (read here). By implication, this means countries like the USA, Australia or UK will never need schools or education because they speak English all their lives. They merely should be born and start transactions. With no regard to why these same countries invest huge sums of money into education, he makes such a serious uninformed statement! 

Let's put things in great perspective - Bill Gates and Steve Jobs were speaking English and writing by the time they got to the 5th grade. So did to Larry Page and Sergey Brin. Their companies started on completely different levels. Some of them dropped out and others earned degrees (PhDs for that fact). Did this stop them from starting companies that deal in information technology? Did they need to merely know how to transact after learning how to speak and write in English? Or take Jack Ma, would he even say his English is close to being perfect? Does he even need English to transact? He needs Chinese to make money.

The bottom line in all this is, one does not need an official or formal education to start a business or to be innovative. It is not a requirement. So why would you judge people on an aspect which is not a requirement in that particular field? 

Take Bill Gates and Steve Jobs as an example - every one knows what they did and how they earned their money. Yet few people (even those reading this blog) know who Larry Page and Sergey Brin are. Why? Because they followed the path which Gates and Jobs did not. So everyone will talk about the most unlikely person to get rich. Simply labeled as you can make it without a degree. Larry Page and Sergey Brin on the other hand have made the money too, but they got through a straight path of degree all the way to PhDs! As of 2016 Forbes richest people in the USA (check here), they are 9th and 10th with a combined worth of $76bn from Google.

So Larry Page and Sergey Brin or indeed Jeff Bezos are not your everyday examples of how to make it in life because, they went through a straight path in education - the dangerous trend in Zambia where we think you need miracles in making it - not hard work! Check how many "pastors" are among the rich people - because they offer you miracles. Say to your neighbour "money" will always ring on a TV screen near you. Yet, none of these would stand and tell you the real thing of working hard to earn what you need. It has even gone into motivation speakers also with questionable qualities. My cousin always says the easiest people to rob are the miracle seekers because they will come and give you even the little they have and go home happy and dancing, not to the police. 

We need to understand the need for hard work or innovation, in order to push for success in our country. Education is a tool to help you understand the world we are in and sharpen your skills in areas important to the individual. Amazon and Google are companies created by people with a degree in computer science or engineering. These skills need an investment in knowing the field. Of course you can hire much educated people like at Microsoft - but can you compare the success of companies/ businesses started by uneducated people and educated ones? Further, not every one is an entrepreneur. Skills and talents differ. 

Ultimately, you can't compare education and entrepreneurship. Clearly where does the debate come from? People can be entrepreneurs with or without an education. Some people have even gone further and said, education is a sure way to have a backup when your innovation is not taken up by the public. I actually think it is an aid to life as it widens knowledge and creativity. For that I would make sure my children get an education level to help them succeed than hope for miracles. Further, even the one who performed the most miracles and died on the cross was not a rich person - so whoever emulates him, should not be covered in wealth, but be a symbol and a true follow of the one he preaches about. 

Thursday, May 30, 2013

Dambisa Moyo Vs. Bill Gates

I was very disappointed to watch Bill Gates' response to a question on Dambisa Moyo's "Dead Aid". Watch

Seriously it is one thing working on codes and programming and living in a country full of poverty and "Aid". Dambisa Moyo is Zambian, a poor country which is a massive recipient of aid. Bill Gates and visisted it on several occasions and probably was taken to meet some of the poor people he "helps" out. But the issue is the experience on the matter and not being a by-stander and being led to meet poor people so you can dish some aid to them. The two have had completely different perspectives of the same thing.

But that is not the issue as I saw it. They are people who have simply empathized on the poor and got a great understanding of the issue in totality  So we would expect that Gates can have a good understanding of the issues that are being addressed here. Maybe even better that Dambisa.

But surely saying Dambisa's book promotes evil is a hit below the belt no matter how much you think you know the issues. I don't think it even comes close to being an insult, it is disgraceful of the man. Look at the facts on the table. I will use some well known sources for easy of reference:

"despite one trillion dollars in western aid over the past sixty years, the economic lot of the average African has only gotten worse. Most Africans now live on one dollar per day, and sub-Saharan Africa remains the poorest region in the world. Despite a deluge of aid between the years of 1970 and 1998, poverty on the continent skyrocketed from 11 percent of the population to 66 percent, which means over six hundred million Africans are now impoverished." (Guernica)

Meaning, the more aid keeps coming to Africa, the poorer the people are becoming. Logically, a rethink of the whole system is in order. But does that re-thinking worth being called "promoting evil"? Surely have respect for intellectual alternative that is being offered. With due respect if this was an area that she has no connection with, you wouldn't disregard one that much, but an economist from Africa talking about an alternative to the system and that is promoting "evil"?

I think the whole thing was probably mis-understood by Gates. Someone credited as being an analyst of great intellectual standing would not go out and literally be so "un-intellectual". I don't think he has even looked at his competitors over the years as that! 

The more I read about the issues, the more I realize the people involved in the debate and unfortunately, can easily be grouped into only two - promoters of aid and promoters of alternative thinking. The promoters are mostly from donor groups or individuals and the alternative thinkers are from poverty and aid recipient countries!

I have never seen anything worth talking about aid. It is mostly used by so called "donors" to get what they want. I even coined a word for one - Gay-Aid. Where the "gay rights" are used in order to get "aid". Malawi is an example of that outcome. Without serious brain gears turning, you reralize the problem of "aid". It does not work to improve people's livelihoods but makes a good thing to use for the west to get their way. African leaders have long been known to use aid to win elections or control certain views all of which do not promote growth and economic prosperity.

On the other hand, if people are being taught to improve and infrastructure built from the financial sector, they would be great responsibility in making sure the goodness of the spirit to build is achieved. This is unlike a situation where one stands with a plate for a donation from Gates foundation to eat. Why would any government think of improving and providing for the people? After all, gates will do it while they steal the wealth through corruption and bribers from west countries' companies. Responsibility and the desire to work and produce results is killed by aid. I seriously look for evidence of a continent that developed from aid! I would be give you a large one which has not move forward over decades because of aid. The facts are on the table not debating the person. 

Guernica and other worthy of read sources have facts that Mr. Gates should have disputed and provided his own facts and not debate the person presenting her facts! It is always that simple!

Sorry, I may get derailed when people disrespect the whole issue of intellectual debate that I may divert myself but when facts are presented, an ad hominem in this time and age is really a hit below the belt!