Showing posts with label windfall tax. Show all posts
Showing posts with label windfall tax. Show all posts

Monday, December 8, 2014

Zambia - The Windfall Tax Story

The issue of windfall tax in Zambia has always been a hot one. Many political ideas have revolved on windfall taxes from the government to the opposition. It is strange that this simple perspective of taxing has been such a hot topic in this country. More so, having implemented it for some time.

So Why the Fights?
Windfall tax is expected to generate a lot of financial rewards for the country in the light of higher copper prices that were witnessed. It is expected to bring in a lot of money to drive the economy. On the other hand, the politicians in the control say it is not possible to introduce a windfall tax. 

The fight got so heated up that some headlines would summarize it. For example it is quoted that those who were calling for windfall tax are lunatics. Check here and here.

Windfall Tax
So what is a windfall tax? The few definitions I came across will sum up as:

"A tax levied by governments against certain industries when economic conditions allow those industries to experience above-average profits." 

"A windfall profits tax is a higher tax rate on profits that ensue from a sudden windfall gain to a particular company or industry."

My favourite for simplistic issues is the last one from Wikipedia because it sums up all elements of the windfall tax and will have all you need for parameters of this discussion. 

Zambia and Windfall Tax
The mining sector in Zambia has an interesting tale. It is booming when the prices are high. However, most if not all mines are in loss making position. So the Corporate Income Tax (CIT) is never paid. On the other hand, mineral royalty (which is deductible) is paid and claimed back.

So the mineral royalty does actually hit the collection point for the nation, but it merely comes as a deposit and is later taken away when one address the issues of their tax position.

Therefore a windfall tax in this position has one element which many have missed - if you are not profitable, you can't pay it! Even when you are profitable, you need to be facing 'windfall profits' or higher than normal profits for the windfall tax to apply! So for a country with a sector that is 90% in loss making position, how then will you apply a windfall tax?

Any economist with the information on the profitability of the mines will find it interesting to call for a windfall tax. Why? How do you get "abnormal profit tax" when the mines have no "profit" in the first place.

The people needed to be told the truth about this. The assumption that everyone talking about windfall tax knew what they were talking about is wrong. people merely voice out what they want regardless of what the situation is on the ground. You need critical issues on the ground for any windfall tax to be implemented. Those parameters are what is missing. 

Where is the Profit?
If the mines had the so called profit position, they would pay taxes. If they made abnormal profits, they would then be a reason to introduce the windfall tax. The lack if profits makes it impossible to have a windfall tax.

Whey mines have no profit is a bigger issue to address and one that will make a good reading and analysis for the future of this country. Many have declared that mines cheat and use tax avoidance schemes to dodge any form of taxation. This has created a bad relationship with government leading to lack of trust between the two. This has led to push and pull issues being done in a way to be better than the other.

If it is true that a lot of cheating has been happening, then the mines will be responsible for this sour relationship and the misery that many people have been exposed to due to lack of resources. On the other hand, we need to ask ourselves as to why mines would go on for decades in a loss-making position. What did we do wrong in the sector? Was the privatization the greatest mistake we made? Can it be corrected?

Where are the profits for a sector that is doing so well in terms of the prices? Calling for a windfall tax without addressing any of this issues is doing the same thing we have been doing all these years and expecting a different result. Albert Einstein once quoted:  ” The definition of insanity is repetitively doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results”. (I have no idea where he was quoted, but that may link well with the lunatic link above). So instead of doing the same thing over and over, we need to do things differently.

One way of doing this differently is to over-look the issue of us sharing in the profits that will never come from the mines. Instead, lets charge them rent on our minerals. What they do with them is not our problem, but pay us for the minerals anyway. This rent is the simplest thing one can use. When you get into a house and rent, the landlord does not care when and how much you are paid, you just pay for the house at the end of the month or at the beginning of the month. If you earn no income in that month, it is not the landlord's fault. This is what is attempted in the 2015 Budget where a royalty will be charged but no CIT. 

The method avoids the chasing of profits on the mines, the transfer pricing issues, etc. It merely requires you to make a payment when the minerals are extracted from the ground. You dig, you pay principle.

Of the two methods, the issue is that both parties (govt andd mines) want to benefit. One method can benefit both, but the lack of trust makes that impossible to carry on. So all these are no alternatives to the issue of sharing the benefits.

Sadly, windfall tax has no effect in the Zambian context at this current situation when there is no profit. So extra or abnormal profits cannot be applied.

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Mining Taxation - What Are We Doing About It?

Many economists in Zambia right now call for windfall tax for the mines in order to make mines contribute their fair share of taxes. Basically the idea is that mining is receiving a lot of returns as the copper prices are high. We should therefore setup a mining tax regime that will be able to capture that "extra" profit that the mines are getting. Its a fair argument and one that makes sense when you look at it. Every work pays taxes, Zambia being a small economy, the taxes needed to provide services are smaller. Therefore the profits that the mines make in a day would nicely cover all the expenses.

However, we must never live believing the mine owners are interested in the wellbeing of Zambians. If they did, the economy of Zambia right now would be far better than were it is right now. Only a fraction of what they get would change everything. But its that greedy and selfishness of mine owners that make the windfall tax a useless path for me. I know a lot of economists would be shocked to hear that. But I have points that need to be taken into consideration before you judge me.

Stealing Benefits Them
Mine owners will do everything they can to steal every little Ngwee they can from Zambia and proudly send it to the west without a problem. Switzerland makes more money from mining of copper than Zambia. Do the Swiss people have windfall tax?

These people will proudly contribute to the tax in Switzerland than Zambia where the copper comes from. All sorts of transfer pricing and complex avoidance of tax methods are employed to make sure they pay nothing to Zambia and pay a lot more to Europe.

The point is, its not the windfall that will make someone eager to steal wealth from our mines to contribute a fair share. They aim at stealing and having a windfall tax when there is a complex plan of transfer pricing, will bring little to the treasury in any case.

Most mines "sell" the produce at "arms length" to their sister companies. Now if that was true, Zambia would raise money tax revenue from copper that Switzerland. Since it isn't, there is a proper case to assume the "arms length" being talked about does not exist. If there was even an ounce of honest in mining companies, the returns from copper would be in levels that we would not complain about.

Government Has Sovereign Right to Tax 
We have to remember for this discussion that a government has the sovereign right to tax. Government is the only power that can tax or not. It has control on what it can tax and how it can tax it."

Allison Christians
"Tax policy creates and reflects relationships between the market, the citizen, and the state. As a result, traditional tax policy discourse centers around the premise that decisions about taxation should be made exclusively within nations, independent of outside concern and interference."

What we need to add to that is that, tax avoidance has outside interference and its that outside force that make certain decisions irrelevant. Windfall tax being one of them. It is easier to avoid the complexity of taxing these companies that make people choose a simple path of windfall tax. I think otherwise. We should remember that our government has the right to tax without interference, and it should make the right decision to tax.

So unless there is no way of detecting the avoidance of tax in the system, the government should make the right decision and take necessary steps to tax all that need to be.

Are We Going Back on Tax?
I always complained about lack of export duty on mineral outputs. Seriously, this is a wasting asset and we allow it to go out of the country without the exporter paying anything? That was a bad thing that the previous government took on board.
 
However, this has been nicely worked on and there is progress in that direction. What worries me is the loss of the "Sovereign Right" to tax. What we cried about on copper seem to have been transferred to Manganese!

Manganese is it now the new plan to change from copper to manganese? Or is it that the new players in the powers are linked to manganese? This is something we need to work on and not go back on taxation.
 
Why allow people to export and not pay for the wasting assests and you complain about the failure of the mining industry to contribute to the revenue share!
 
Nothing is more to my heart that a failure of the system due to the people involved in it. Seriously, we have the most sacred job of taking care of the country now for future generations to benefit from the wealth that we have. But the moment we come into the picture, we come up with plans of making sure people "steal" the assets that are needed to develop the country. We should not make statements which are parallel to what is happening on the gorund we must take it upon ourselves to ensure we do what is right for the nation. This clearly is not happening at the moment. It has not been happening for the past 30years or so. Zambia is bigger than all of us and we must be within our powers what is right.
I seriously didn't expect that the country's wealth will continue getting out of this country without paying the simplest of all charges - export duty. But it is happening.